Post by optimist on Sept 28, 2009 11:06:26 GMT -5
I thought this merited its own thread. As a couple of people have already highlighted Minesh & Ash are being sued in Texas for copyright infringement.
dockets.justia.com/docket/court-txndce/case_no-3:2008cv01054/case_id-177907/
They went on some seminars back in March/April 2007 with Compound Stock Earnings Inc. and, according to the lawsuit, lifted large chunks of the CSE manual for the CFL manual - albeit, the more descriptive what is a stock, what is an option kind of thing, according to the original filing (although CSE have recently been given permission to amend their complaint).
The case is not going well for the London boys. All the motions being made by CSE are being granted by the judge. And stuff like the following does not sound good:
"IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that Defendant Soni Finance, Ltd. (by and through its authorized representative Vijay Shah) and any agent, employee, or representative of Defendant Soni Finance Ltd. comport themselves with respect in their contacts with opposing counsel and to refrain from making threats;"
This was about 6 weeks ago, so will go some way perhaps to explaining the lack of focus people are mentioning.
It doesn't mean what they are teaching doesn't work - it just means it's not original. What it does mean though is that they haven't been doing it for years and years as they claim. They had a good idea (if it works in the US, teach it in the UK) but Minesh has been caught out because he was lazy and copied stuff out word for word from the CSE manual. Silly.
dockets.justia.com/docket/court-txndce/case_no-3:2008cv01054/case_id-177907/
They went on some seminars back in March/April 2007 with Compound Stock Earnings Inc. and, according to the lawsuit, lifted large chunks of the CSE manual for the CFL manual - albeit, the more descriptive what is a stock, what is an option kind of thing, according to the original filing (although CSE have recently been given permission to amend their complaint).
The case is not going well for the London boys. All the motions being made by CSE are being granted by the judge. And stuff like the following does not sound good:
"IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that Defendant Soni Finance, Ltd. (by and through its authorized representative Vijay Shah) and any agent, employee, or representative of Defendant Soni Finance Ltd. comport themselves with respect in their contacts with opposing counsel and to refrain from making threats;"
This was about 6 weeks ago, so will go some way perhaps to explaining the lack of focus people are mentioning.
It doesn't mean what they are teaching doesn't work - it just means it's not original. What it does mean though is that they haven't been doing it for years and years as they claim. They had a good idea (if it works in the US, teach it in the UK) but Minesh has been caught out because he was lazy and copied stuff out word for word from the CSE manual. Silly.